Q: Is Windows Defender enough to keep my computer safe from viruses?

Q: Is Windows Defender enough to keep my computer safe from viruses? I used to have Norton but my son says it is malware and all it does is use a big chunk of my cpu and slow my computer down. He claims to never have had a virus on his computer and that he has never installed anti-virus software. I don't understand how this is possible.

A: Let’s break this down, I think this is a wonderful opportunity for the son to learn the distinction between belief and evidence:

  • Norton 360 is malware.If you look up the definition of malware, in no way does Norton 360 fall into that category. Score 0 for son.
  • All it does is use a big chunk of cup and slow my computer down. This is a testable statement. Check out av-comparatives.org, and look at the most current performance test. This lists the impact antivirus software has on your system. The lowest rating is by ESET, with a score of 5.6. Symantec is 5.7, Microsoft’s own is 36.7 (the highest rating). In this case, lower is better. So, score 0 for son.
  • He claims to never have had a virus on his computer. How would he know? Well-crafted malware is not detectable by the end user. It is the poorly designed malware that causes detectable problems. By some estimates, up to 40% of Windows systems are infected (I personally find this state low. Almost every Windows system that is brought to us is infected with something, but we are in that business.) Score 0 for son.
  • Now, as to your question about Windows Defender, again, this is testable. By reviewing http://av-comparatives.org test results on Defender, it rated #10 in real-world protection at 99.5% with 5 false positives, and its impact on performance is answered above. Is MS Defender a poor choice? No. But it is very far from the best choice - and it slows down the computer more than most commercial offerings.

I’d say this is another case where father knows best.

No Comments Yet.

Leave a comment

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close